Very dissapointing. I hope Obama will adopt from a shelter.

Posted by: Aneliese | December 12, 2008 11:25 AM

I really hope that Obama has the heart to adopt his daughters' dog from a shelter and not a breeder or pet store. I love the video, though. =]

Posted by: Katrina Paluso | December 12, 2008 12:01 PM

Is it really that difficult to adopt a dog from a shelter? Even if you have no compassion, you obviously know that Animal Rights activists are looking at you but you couldn't care less. From today on, I don't trust a damned thing you do.
It's all about the money. The AKC is full of WASPy rich f***ers and I know they have leverage with politicians. Mark my words, Obama will buy one and get one killed as well. He already started to make excuses. He knew his daughter had allergies the first time he said he would adopt from a shelter. After he got elected he changed his tune. Sick and disappointing.

Posted by: Anita50882 | December 12, 2008 12:45 PM

So sad. I used to respect that man.

Posted by: Lianne | December 12, 2008 12:59 PM

The worst part about this is I just attended a benefit at a local Delaware shelter where Biden was a guest of honor! And he got up there and went on about how he supports the shelter's efforts. I guess not enough to rescue from them.

Posted by: Rez | December 12, 2008 01:35 PM

Joe Biden

Sucks.

Tom

Posted by: Tom | December 12, 2008 01:57 PM

I am very disappointed in Mr. Biden. I sincerely hope this isn't a harbinger of callous policies to come towards animals, but I agree with Anita. Suddenly I am not so sure.

Posted by: David | December 12, 2008 02:04 PM

Shame on you Mr. Biden!

Posted by: Susan | December 12, 2008 02:06 PM

Well seven years ago, when I was ten, my parents got our dog, a sweet westie named Biscuit, from a breeder and we love her so much- but when I get my own place, I'll get shelter dogs or cats. I mean, at the shelter closest to my house, it's disturbing how they literally have to stack cat carriers (with cats in them) on top of each other because there are so many kitties!

Posted by: Anna | December 12, 2008 02:40 PM

It's tough being in the public eye - everyone wants to tell you how to live your life!

"You can't please everyone so you've got to please yourself."

Rick Nelson

Posted by: Donna Hughes | December 12, 2008 04:40 PM

hello from Australia. I have just received the petition about China and the fur trade and then read the note about Biden. Is someone going to be able to get Barrack Obama - who is clearly aware of the case for adopting dogs from shelters - into the international discussion about animal cruelty?? we cannot let this horror continue. Here in Australia I will do all I can to join with those who try to bring it to the attention of our politicians. We rely on trade with China so heavily .. no doubt there are blind eyes already turned! But I shall try to get friends as well as my already committed family into this struggle. Strength to you all!

Posted by: Yvonne Lynton Reid | December 12, 2008 05:20 PM

WE CAN'T GIVE UP! At least we tried. But maybe Obama will get his from a shelter.But it is sad that he made that decision. Glad the PSA is going to be put back on the air to keep the message out there.

Posted by: SASHA | December 12, 2008 05:43 PM

When did Joe Biden buy this dog? Was it recently or has he had the dog for a while, before finding out that you should adopt a dog and not buy one? I am curious to know that maybe if he did buy the dog a while ago, maybe we should give him the benefit of the doubt.But if it was a recent purchase, that would be terrible! I just hope Obama sticks to his word and adopts.

Posted by: Rex's Mom | December 12, 2008 05:55 PM

Yeah Rick, it's all about pleasing the humans. Another dead dog - oh well. Biden; just another selfish, self-serving out of touch pol.

Posted by: Peter Wood | December 12, 2008 06:27 PM

I hope Biden is feeling ashamed, but I seriously doubt it. I think Obama will receive a lot of flack if he doesn't adopt from a shelter. If they can't find one right away that meets the allergy requirements, then they should wait until a dog becomes available that does. Pet stores should be banned from selling cats, dogs, and rabbits. These animals are usually always available in a shelter.

Posted by: pam | December 12, 2008 10:04 PM

So what? He supported the economy!

Posted by: J | December 12, 2008 11:49 PM

There's nothing wrong with getting a dog from a good breeder. If all breeders stopped breeding then dogs would cease to exist. Not all breeders are puppymillers. There are good breeders and bad breeders. There is nothing wrong with wanting a dog from a good breeder.

Posted by: Laura | December 13, 2008 12:55 AM

wait a minute. igloos? blue plastic? that is very misleading. could be that igloos are really big doghouses and that blue plastic is just keeping somethig dry, like woodpiles and other normal things.

i am still all for adopting dogs, nd even MORE for keeping them out of shlters in the first place, but we cant judge people using information of that sort.

Posted by: cilantro | December 13, 2008 02:09 AM

Although Joe Biden is a better choice than Sara Palin (the animal destroyer) this was a bad choice Joe. Not only should you think before you open your mouth as you have been advised, you should also stop and think before you act. And in this case both. Your words and actions are hypocritical. Your words back shelters, your actions buy from puppy mills. Shame on you Joe!

Posted by: Claudia | December 13, 2008 04:33 AM

So Biden was stuid enough to get ripped off by a puppy mill?

What doers that say about his ability as VP?

And a puppy mill that, I bet, isn't reporting their income and isn't paying their TAXES!

Most of these mills hide their income and cheat on taxes

Let's look into the business dealings of this puppy miller

Posted by: kelly | December 13, 2008 07:47 AM

And the AKC makes most of its money registering PUPPY MILL DOGS!

http://www.bogartsdaddy.com/Bouvier/Bouv_Pages/article-inquire-puppymills-AKC.htm

Posted by: kelly | December 13, 2008 07:48 AM

This puppy mill breeder has aLREADY gotten caught in fraud

http://www.pet-abuse.com/cases/8439/PA/US/ummmm so much for respectable breeder- AKC nailed her for falsifying paperwork. http://www.pet-abuse.com/cases/8439/PA/US/

She was falsifying paperwork!!

Biden got cheated by a fraudster!!!

Posted by: kelly | December 13, 2008 08:21 AM

I totally agree that Biden should have adopted a dog from an animal shelter rather than a breeder. However, we all know the conditions of puppyy mills are disgusting. So if Biden did adopt a puppy from a puppy mill, can't we look at as though that is one less innocent animals that has to live in those conditions?

Posted by: Hayleigh | December 13, 2008 09:15 AM

Joe Biden adhere to the lobbyist of the american kennels. what a loser

Posted by: roxanne | December 13, 2008 09:18 AM

I was so disappointed to read that in the paper this morning. It said he bought the puppy at the home oe Chester County breeder Linda Brown and the Washington Post has a picture of her with the puppy. I really hope she isn't a puppy mill operator! I don't think he's been lobbied as much as Obama about adopting from a shelter, but if at least some groups contacted him and another reader said he attended an event at an animal shelter he has no excuse to not know about the reasons to adopt. We often have German shepard puppies at my shelter and we would've been happy to adopt one to him. In addition to adoption being life or death for animals, there's also the aspect that buying from a breeder is elitist. Most of the people in this country can't afford to do that. Plus, many animals from people affected from the economic shelters are now in the shelters he bypassed. I really hope Obama doesn't renege on his promise to adopt. He can find hypoallergenic breeds at shelters, too.

Posted by: clarissa | December 13, 2008 10:12 AM

Not surprised--Mr. Biden is not to be trusted; in politics or personal life, his history tells the true story.
Thanks to PETA though--he won't be able to forget another bad move by adopting thru a puppy mill.
Thanks PETA-again for keeping up on everything that involves animals.

Posted by: Debbie | December 13, 2008 11:07 AM

WOW! Has this guy been living in a cave or something? With all the exposure on puppy mills in the last few months, you'd think he would go to a shelter to adopt even if it was only to score political points.
What an idiot!

Posted by: NT | December 13, 2008 09:21 PM

This is disappointing to hear. However, we cannot make blanket statements like "He sucks" based on this one misguided choice. I am certain he will be a much better VP and a MUCH better environmental/animal advocate than Dick Cheney!! Here's hoping Obama adopts from a shelter.

Posted by: Renae | December 14, 2008 12:02 AM

It's a shame he chose to do that :( I hope Obama does the compassionate thing and adopt one of those mutts "Like him"

Allie

Posted by: Allie | December 14, 2008 01:51 PM

I am not at all surprised. He is a typical, "Do as I say, not as I do" liberal. Atrocious Mr. Biden.

Posted by: Amanda | December 14, 2008 01:54 PM

what an ass

Posted by: farah | December 14, 2008 02:13 PM

I've loved Joe Biden forever, so very disappointed with his selection of a breeder instead of the shelters!!!! Come on Joe, you should have know better!!!!!!!

Posted by: shelva wood | December 14, 2008 04:20 PM

I agree, this is terrible. Joe Biden should have rescued a dog and maybe he will change his mind. I am so sad with this decision, I now have a total different opinion of him.

Posted by: ruth eagen | December 14, 2008 04:22 PM

Joe once again proves he is a elistist, a rescue dog wasnt good enough for him? only saving grace is that a shepherd will be smarter than joe and should have him fully trained in by the time it is a years old. joe is a bad bad man. I own an aussie shepherd mix puppy from a rescue operation her mom was aussie her dad a shepherd and at a year old she is smarter than vp elect biden. joe is and always will be such a big disappointment

Posted by: Ian | December 14, 2008 04:25 PM

I just can't understand how a capitalist politician would buy from a puppy mill. I mean puppy mills go against everything that capitalism is about, i.e exploitation and profit.

This really is shocking.

Posted by: Chris Moncado | December 14, 2008 05:10 PM

It is kind of strange it`s as if he did it to support breeders.
I`m sure Obama will set a much more compassionate example after all the world is also watching!

Posted by: Rosiewoods | December 14, 2008 05:16 PM

love the video it was hilarious.

Posted by: kaylen | December 14, 2008 06:36 PM

Don't breed or buy while homeless animals die.
Opt to adopt and
save a hound from the pound.

Posted by: Bob | December 14, 2008 08:02 PM

This just sends the wrong message. We all know that it means another dog will have to be killed at the shelter - so more tax dollars. By adopting a dog he would have shown that we can spend tax money on education of children - perhaps teaching his grandchildren to Adopt and not Shop for a puppy.

Posted by: Manuel | December 15, 2008 02:06 AM

I saw this on the sunday morning news and my heart sank, than I got pissed. The lady selling the puppy was all smiles. Yeah right lady! Planning on torturing more animals for profit. Now that our creepy Vice President Elect, you know the regular guy, bought a dog from you. Well, Joe Biden your getting a letter from me as soon as I compose myself. From the stupidy you have displayed to the American people. Or was there a payoff from someone to buy from a breeder.

Posted by: Joyce Son | December 15, 2008 01:08 PM

"I just can't understand how a capitalist politician would buy from a puppy mill. I mean puppy mills go against everything that capitalism is about, i.e exploitation and profit.

This really is shocking."

Good point, america is nothing but a corruptocracy.

That's what happens when compassion isn't on the menu.

Think Green and go veg.

Posted by: vegancoin | December 15, 2008 05:58 PM

Joe--how could you do something so selfish and shortsighted. I can't even tell you how dissapointed I am with you.

Hayleigh--the big problem isn't with the puppies, they are worth money to the breeders, so they get a bit of attention. The real suffering happens to their mothers and fathers who are forced to breed over and over again until they are all used up.

Posted by: Kelley | December 15, 2008 06:47 PM

Is a campaign being formed to contact Senator Biden, and request that he now ADOPT a dog.
(Two dogs are better than one.)

Posted by: Pat | December 16, 2008 12:40 PM

Amanda,

Are you implying that conservatives always follow through with what they preach? It is difficult to judge tone on message boards, so I hope you are merely a fed-up liberal and not a Palin supporter whose brain cell mass diminished simply by watching Palin struggle to understand basic english.

Posted by: Derek, MD | December 16, 2008 01:44 PM

I'm a PETA supporter, but think this ad should be reconsidered, as I believe it is more likely to produce backlash against the organization and its very meritorious goals than to achieve the goal of promoting adoption of shelter pets.

Though it is disappointing that individuals, including Sen. Biden, who are looking for a new pet do not make the choice to save a shelter pet rather than purchase from a breeder, it's actually no more correct to say he "killed a shelter pet" than it is to say you or I or anyone who did not even consider adopting a pet on any given day "killed" all the pets who were euthanized there that day.

Unless Sen. Biden abandoned a pet to a shelter or (different issue) purchased from a puppy mill rather than a responsible and humane breeder of purebred animals, I think attacking him and his choice is by association attacking many responsible pet owners and a large population of passionate animal lovers who do own purebred dogs or cats and really could be strong supporters of a lot of PETA goals.

Something to consider!

Posted by: Priscilla | December 16, 2008 01:55 PM

Did anyone catch this story about the kennel getting cited?: http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/harrisburg_politics/Kennel_where_Biden_bought_puppy_is_cited.html

Rather sounds like he bought from a puppy miller and, really, I think he got a dog for the wrong reasons. Very disappointing

Posted by: Jenn | December 16, 2008 10:22 PM

He should have adopted.

Posted by: Tammy | December 17, 2008 07:10 AM

Biden is not only a loud mouth, but now a liar. He does not even strike me as an animal lover! I cannot believe he even went to a shelter and said all he said while he bought his dogs from a breeder/puppy mill....Ugh! Shame on you Biden!!!!

Posted by: viv | December 17, 2008 09:40 AM

Joe Biden will hold the 2nd highest office in the country, therefore, he serves as an example for all people throughout our great country in leadership and integrity. Fact.

The purchase of a dog from a commercial kennel sends a message to the American public that it is ok to continue to purchase dogs rather than adopt one of the thousands that need homes across America.

The purchase of a dog from a commercial kennel in fact prevents a homeless dog from being adopted into a loving home. Fact.

The purchase of a dog from a commerical kennel will ultimately send a homeless dog to the gas chamber or succomb to lethal injection. Fact.

The purchase of a dog from a commercial kennel steps on the hopes and dreams as well as hard work of shelter workers, shelter volunteers, and animal protection agencies who give of themselves every single day to help animals. Fact.

The purchase of a dog from a commercial kennel will in no way guarantee temperament. Every dog is a unique individual, and all dogs require supervision around children. There are many homeless dogs across the US with sweet and gentle temperaments. Fact.

The purchase of a dog from a commercial kennel may not result in a dog with fewer medical problems when purchased from a reputable breeder. Many medical problems rise from improper diet and exercise. Medical problems should NEVER be a reason not to adopt a poor dog that needs a home. If a homeless dog is not adopted, it will surely have its worth medical problem. Death. Fact.

Joe Biden's personal decision carries with it great consquences for homeless dogs across America. Fact.

Posted by: Tracy Murphy | December 17, 2008 05:30 PM

Hello everyone. I am a person who is trying so hard to help our animals and changing over to being vegetarian. We are eating less meat and only meat from humane farmers.

We are all trying, within our economic capablities to either be vegetarian or eat meat that is raised and delivered to us in humane ways. Not easy, I realize. Also we have to realize that we need to spend at least 100% more if we want to eat meat.!

I truly believe that there needs to be more education for people on how they can develop meals that are not meat based.

We voted for Obama and Biden and we want them to support our issues in relation to animals raised in humane conditions.

I guess this is one of the first areas where we should all realize that our vote is not getting us what we want.

I am also disappointed.

Renee Jones

Posted by: Renee Jones | December 18, 2008 06:58 PM

I wish he'd adopted, but it's ridiculous to say people are going to "run out" and buy German Shepherd Dogs because of this. Like yeah, because we all look to Joe Biden before we make a decision, amirite? This isn't the '60s, when women wanted to dress like Jackie, nobody cares anymore ... That's like saying all Clinton's supporters ran out and had affairs in '98. (Psst, we didn't ... in case you were confused.) I hope we can have more faith in the American people than we can in Biden.

Posted by: Liza | December 18, 2008 07:53 PM

I'm from Delaware and VERY disappointed in Biden. I really thought he was a compassionate man -- now I'm re-thinking that...I hope Obama does the RIGHT and HUMANE thing and adopt from a shelter/rescue.

Posted by: Barbara | December 18, 2008 08:02 PM

I am really disappointed in the vice president. it goes to show that even though they are suppose to be a team in the white house they still do not agree on everything. I hope Mr obama sticks to his pledge to get a pound dog. there has to be a beautiful full blooded dog that some one gave up in a pound somewhere in the states he could adopt for his girls. the mixed breeds are acutally the best and smartest anyway.

Posted by: JulieAnn Zserdin | December 18, 2008 08:17 PM

Say it aint so Joe!

Posted by: Adam G. | December 18, 2008 09:10 PM

Biden is a phony. I feel sorry for whomever has to be his dog. Poor puppy better sleep with one eye open.

Posted by: Friendly | December 18, 2008 09:29 PM

I just hope Biden does something about the fur trade in China and other countries. These dogs suffer and we still buy from China.

Posted by: Robert | December 18, 2008 11:04 PM

That's horrible.
What a tragic thing to do.

Posted by: Jerry | December 18, 2008 11:12 PM

I am disappointed in him as well as everyone else. Maybe we can urge him to adopt one. Dogs love playmates

Posted by: Victoria | December 19, 2008 08:01 AM

I am so disappointed that Biden didn't go to a shelter and adopt a pet. There are SO many wonderful dogs there, purebred and/or mixed, and surely he would have found one just a nice and would have saved a life at the same time. Disappointing, Joe Biden!

Posted by: Debbie G | December 19, 2008 08:04 AM

It is surprising that the VP and his wife are is so ignorant of the reality behind the Breeding houses.
How will the people behave who have elected such indifferent person as the VP.
Shame on America

Posted by: Raja | December 19, 2008 08:20 AM

I am highly disappointed with Mr. Biden's decision to buy a dog when six million wonderful pets are killed every year. I hope Obama does not make the same mistake.

Posted by: Nadia Boone | December 19, 2008 08:32 AM

Talk about someone that has no brains that is Biden. Instead of going to a shelter he went to place that over charges of animals and God knows if that dog isn't cross bread.
It would have looked better if he had safed a dog's life and he would have looked better but everybody has a right to get their dogs wherever they want to.
"Freedom of Choice" in this country and that is a fact.
He just made a bad choice so he has to live with it and that is another fact.

Posted by: Carol | December 19, 2008 09:20 AM

Biden and Obama are turning out to be like so many other political scumbags. I am Very Dissapointed at you Mr. Biden, you should be ashamed of yourself.

Posted by: Vicky | December 19, 2008 09:26 AM

I was sick with disappointment after hearing Biden's decision - and of course, it was blasted all over the news. I felt like it was a huge loss for the home team. I was jumping for joy when the Obama/Biden team won the election and now I'm embarrassed beyond belief that I voted for someone who displays this much arrogance. Especially someone who claims they understand the importance of rescuing. Such a sad defeat for shelter animals everywhere...

Posted by: Erica Kahunanui | December 19, 2008 09:45 AM

I do agree that some breeders are families that work small scale and are not necessarily bad people. I also would never buy an animal from a pet store unless the animals were being adopted out because they were left without homes, as shelter animals are (whether they are born in the wild or "dropped off"). Sometimes people consider breeders because they want a specific breed of dog for a specific purpose (such as protection), or they want a puppy because they want a dog who will grow with their young child. Does anyone know anything about shepards and young children? My husband and I are considering buying a shepard from a breeder because we are afraid if we get an older dog it might not bond as well with our child. We are looking for a dog who will become an intimate part of our family and also will be protective of us and our home. Not all types of dogs are good with children and not all types of dogs are protective of both people and property. Forgive me if I sound ignorant; I am super into animal rights and am mommy to an adopted cat (she was left at my door by a friend who knows I love animals). It's just that, for some people, certain types of dogs are not a good fit and might not be practical.

Posted by: Talia | December 19, 2008 10:18 AM

As Americans we have the right to buy a dog from a reputable breeder. A puppy mill - no, but a reputable breeder who is an expert - by all means. No one has the right to try and strong-arm anyone into adopting rather than buying their pet.

Posted by: N Dougherty | December 19, 2008 11:01 AM

J stated:
"There's nothing wrong with getting a dog from a good breeder. If all breeders stopped breeding then dogs would cease to exist."

You're serious, aren't you?

I'm not attacking anyone here, but to be sure, there were dogs before there were breeders. "Purebreeds," cute as they may be, are much more predisposed to health problems and die earlier than "mutts." Why keep making more when there are so many wonderful adoptable dogs here already? This can apply not only to dogs, but other animals and even goods and products.

We were given a purebred, show-quality shar-pei by a breeder our vet knew many years ago. His tail had been broken during birth and was crooked so he wasn't able to be shown (not perfect enough). Pugsley was a wonderful companion for 7 years, BUT the vet bills were astronomical, and 7 short years is not enough time for such a good pet. He eventually succumbed to cancer. It is far more humane to adopt, and I don't think we're as in control of the dog population was we think we may be.

Posted by: Chris | December 19, 2008 11:21 AM

There are so many unwanted animals in shelters that need a good home that I wish Joe Biden would have adopted a dog from a shelter. There is no need to breed anymore animals when so many need a home.

As Vice President you have to set an example for the rest of the people. I belive that
President-elect Obama will.

Posted by: Barbara Chichester | December 19, 2008 11:30 AM

That video was excellent, hope soeone sent it to Biden

Posted by: Norma Campbell | December 19, 2008 12:31 PM

So how about pressuring Biden into getting another dog, this time from a shelter, so that the puppy with have a companion.? Dogs are much happier when they have one of their own to play with!

Posted by: M.H. | December 19, 2008 12:37 PM

WAY TO GO JOE!!! SCREWED UP ALREADY!!

Posted by: Vicki Orr | December 19, 2008 12:44 PM

Typical politician. Says one thing. Does another.

Posted by: GAVIN KENLY | December 19, 2008 02:19 PM

I was so disappointed when I saw this story air on TV that I immediately send Mr. Biden a message via his website. What was he thinking? I really thought he was a compassionate man, but I guess he fooled us all. There are plenty of German Shephards who need homes - even pure bred puppies. Boo to you Mr. Biden.

Posted by: Sangeeta | December 19, 2008 02:20 PM

You are dreaming if you think any politicians keep most campaign promises. They all have a million excuses for not following through. Ignorance also plagues most of them and it is non partisan.

Posted by: Barbara Hanson | December 19, 2008 04:02 PM

Talia, you are in the wrong place to ask advice on buying a dog. Part of animal rights is acknowledging that animals are not things to be bought and sold. Try searching petfinder.com for GSD pups, there are plenty out there who desperately need homes.

Posted by: Elphaba | December 19, 2008 04:10 PM

I am not surprise that he got the dog from a breeder. I cannot see him taken any time for walking thou a shelter to look for a dog like he will not take time to look out for the the average working person.

Posted by: nancy ferrell | December 19, 2008 06:56 PM

what happens to the breeder's puppies that go unsold? do those also end up in shelters? once again PETA's logic is off.

either way it is a dog that gets a loving home. shouldn't that be what really matters?

Posted by: soigoinsane | December 19, 2008 07:56 PM

Joe Biden aside...puppies from breeders need homes too. How can PETA say that some dogs are worth bringing home and others aren't because by chance they were born to a breeder/puppy mill? Telling people that adopting is the only right way still leaves thousands of dogs homeless. So until someone finds a way to shut down all puppy mills and finds every single dog a home...i say bring home whatever dog you want from wherever you want because every dog needs a home.

Posted by: Mariko Lanoue | December 19, 2008 08:14 PM

I agree that he should have adopted a pet. But you can't go around critisizing every one that buys or sells a certain breed of dogs. You are making the people who breed them and take excellent care of their animals look bad. I have a friend who breeds White German Sheppards (not sure exactly what the breed is called) who takes EXCELLENT care of her animals. She takes them to the vet regularly and has a family who loves the dogs. She sells them for a second income so she can support her family. You are chastising every one because of the conditions some people put their dogs through. I don't agree with the way puppy-mills treat their animals either. But at the same time, I don't agree with a lot of things PETA does.

Posted by: Cecilia | December 19, 2008 08:18 PM

You know I have never really listened to things that PETA has to say. I mean I am not by any means cruel to animals but not a veegan either. However, that PSA really hit home with me. I just lost the most special pet I ever had a few months ago and we got that special siamese cat from the shelter in Watertown, NY. Why Mr. Biden couldn't find a special pet there is beyond me. I know people of his stature think they have to have some piece of paper that says their pet is special but no pieces of paper could ever have made my cat any more special to me. What a bum.

Posted by: Tim O'Donnell | December 19, 2008 08:22 PM

It's isn't like when you purchase a dog the shelter gets word and then they slay another dog. It doesn't work that way.
If the man wants to buy a dog, let him buy a dog. It's his money and his choice.

Posted by: Brittany | December 19, 2008 08:24 PM

While I in NO WAY would ever knowingly support any type of puppy mill or anything remotely like that.....I have a Yellow Lab and two Great Danes, all three of which I purchased from breeders. I support getting a pet from a shelter 100%, but I don't think buying a dog from a breeder means that another dog lost a life.....How do we know the dogs we bought wouldn't end up in the shelter if we wouldn't have bought them? IT's the people who breed the dogs not the people who buy the dogs that are alredy born.

Posted by: Michele | December 19, 2008 08:24 PM

To bad for Joe, my rescue dog beats a pure breed anyday. He's so special he's his very own breed... You go Ajax, you rock.

Posted by: Ann | December 19, 2008 08:39 PM

I didn't vote for Obama/Biden, but their choice of pooches is hardly my concern, and I found it cheezy when Obama mentioned the puppy in his acceptance speech. If I were to get a dog or another cat I would likely adopt again. It has worked out well. But certain breeds have particular attributes that the dogowner is looking for. I also have horses...and in my book, there is nothing better than a well bred Morgan. Peta is making too much of this...as they are wont to do.

Posted by: Renay | December 19, 2008 08:50 PM

In this day and age of information access I am shocked that people on OUR payroll are so ignorant. Do they think they are getting a healthier dog? Wrong. Do they think they are making a smart financial decision. Wrong. I hope they work better & smarter for us than they do for themselves.

Posted by: MJ | December 19, 2008 10:02 PM

I know people who work with dogs and breed dogs. Like them I understand the reason for not buying dogs from puppy mills. However, buying a dog from a reputable dealer is fine. People buy pedigree dogs for various reasons usually one regarding temperament.

I understand PETA's desire to rally up for animals and their mistreatments. The problem I have with them, and many other groups, is they go to far in the name of PC. PETA has become a major PITA and I hope they can scale it back. I do think basically they are a wonderful watchdog, no pun intended, group.

Posted by: Sherri | December 19, 2008 10:46 PM

PETA PEOPLE : Hurry & draw up a letter for all friends to sign re. the very thoughtless decision made by Mr Biden to have BOUGHT a dog from a BREEDER. When all of us have signed, have it delivered to Mr Biden's home .

Posted by: michele6933 | December 20, 2008 12:13 AM

Joe Biden eats animals, so why would he care where "his pet" comes from? I have no respect for this person.

Posted by: Erlyn | December 20, 2008 01:24 AM

I got two Fox Terriers from a kill shelter in Brownwood. I saw them on the internet, they were brought to the shelter with four other siblings. These puppies came from a breeder who was upset that a Yorkie got her Fox terrier pregnant and wanted them all put to sleep. The shelter told her they would try and find homes first. They were only five weeks old when brought in and my little Zoey only weight 2lbs 4 ozs and had Parvo, her brother Taz had a liver condtion. They are both healthy and happy now. They were not cheap to get that way but worth every penny. Shelter dogs are so appreciative.

Posted by: Peggy | December 20, 2008 03:34 AM

Good grief everyone,,,STOP. Take a breath. Does "anyone" really know WHERE he got his dog? If a breeder, anyone know "anything" about them. Give the guy a break. I literally have had 100's of animals - some strays, from shelters and some from registered breeders. The main point is - we ALL have our favorites. Feed them, love them and care for them - ALL. Everyone is so very quick to judge. I think we still have "choices" in America don't we??? God Bless and Merry Christmas to all,,,,

Posted by: Alinda Bruce | December 20, 2008 03:43 AM

I just read Ingrid's letter. Although it was upbeat and a very nicely written letter, it did not include a very important fact. The fact that there are purebreds available in shelters as well. Joe Biden chose a German Shepherd because he really liked the breed. Some of these guys just don't have the time to learn that purebreds are available as well (remember Barack Obama's comments on all dogs being mutts like himself in shelters). Please don't miss this important fact again in Ingrid's letters.

Posted by: Tracy Murphy | December 20, 2008 06:36 AM

No politician gives a crap about anything or anyone but themselves. We can only hope that in their next life, they are born in a puppy mill...

Posted by: Elaine | December 20, 2008 06:45 AM

I too, was saddened and disappointed in Mr. Biden's choice. I knew that there would be an outcry amongst us shelter animal people. I'm a "adopter" I recently lost my 15 year old shelter pup and live with my beautiful "dumpster" kitty.
I am also a fair person and understand that there is a case for purebred dogs too.
What I immediately thought when I heard this news is that I hoped that the Bidens, in an attempt at "balance" (especially given the pro shelter animal state they're from) would also adopt a pup from a shelter!
THAT would certainly help spread the idea.....
A--- who sorely misses her shelter pup!

Posted by: Andrea | December 20, 2008 10:54 AM

Look at it this way. If Biden had gone the shelter route, there would be one photo, and that would be it. Now, the story is being carried everywhere, and people are getting the word that there are hundreds of bad breeders, and that shelters are having to kill thousands of dogs.

Posted by: lilli | December 20, 2008 11:05 AM

I TOO AM VERY DISAPPOINTED. IT SEEMS THAT PEOPLE THAT ARE IN THEIR POSITIONS SHOULD BE AWARE OF WHAT THE CONSEQUENCES WOULD BE AND THE REACTION OF THE PUBLIC. AFTER ALL THE DEVELOPING IN THIS COUNTRY, EVERY DAY, THERE ARE POOR ANIMAL THAT HAVE DIED BY OUR CARS DUE TO NO HOMES, THERE SHOULD BE NO ANIMAL PUT TO SLEEP UNLESS THEY ARE ILL. WHAT IS IT THAT WE ARE DOING TO OUR WILDLIFE AND PETS?

Posted by: DEBORAH MILGRIM | December 20, 2008 11:20 AM

I,m so glad that Jesus died for us, and that he is sitting at the side of the Father interceding for us, because we condem people, and act like we are perfect. What did you all do wrong today that we will never know about, because you are not in the spotlight. One thing i do know, is that God has an all seeing eye, and he,s watching you as well as me. Stop judging people and PRAY for that man. Its time out for all this mess. I got thre right to say this , because i love dogs and any other kind of animal. I have taken in 8 dogs all from the shelter or someone give them to me, because they could,nt keep them anymore. I,m also a vietnam veteran that love this country and its time that we act like we acked in nam when we had to fight the enemy. or like we acted after (911)COME TOGETHER FOLKS, GOD IS NOT PLEASED.

Posted by: Tommy L Moore | December 20, 2008 11:44 AM

I adopted my little boy, a purebred Pekingese, from the shelter in Sept. '99, and he has brought joy to my life every day since. Shame on Biden for not buying from a shelter. I didn't realize that in Delaware, for every dog bought from a breeder, one dog in a shelter is killed. Biden has to realize that he is now under a microscope, and has to do the PC thing. There are purebred dogs in shelters, including german shepherd puppies, so shame on him for not getting one at his local shelter.

Posted by: Deb | December 20, 2008 11:55 AM

I am buying a goldendoodle from a breeder.

Posted by: Adam | December 20, 2008 11:57 AM

I disagree. When buying a German Shephard, you want it registered with a history of it's bloodline. This helps assure you that the dog does not have the hip/rear leg desease which are very common among this breed. Pups cannot be x rayed for a prognosis until a mimimum of 8 months
before they know the animal is free from this condition.

Posted by: J G | December 20, 2008 12:19 PM

Little publisized fact one should know about shelter animals that are put down, they are sent to schools teaching medicine. While it is sad that many end up in the garbage, many are training the same people that will be medically treating us for the rest of our lives. There is another problem with shelter dogs, you don't know where they came from. Puppies may be different as one could assume that they haven't as of yet been abused, but I don't like full grown dogs I do know playing with my small children.

Posted by: lauren | December 20, 2008 12:20 PM

I myself have never bought a dog. I generally get them from freinds that have to many and are looking for homes for the them, but Biden has the right to purchase a dog if he likes. It isn't PETA's or you right to tell him what to do. You people need to get real. Let Peta adopt all the animals.

Posted by: Mike | December 20, 2008 12:21 PM

Are you kidding me? I mean really Joe Biden is one person and now the whole world is going crazy that he didn't adopt? It's his life let him live it and don't judge him.

Posted by: Max | December 20, 2008 12:24 PM

I have always adopted from a shelter....about 20 years ago when the Humane Society called me and said they had 15 rabbits that needed a home I decided ENOUGH was enough.....I already had 4 cats, 4 dogs a dozen or so gunnie pigs and about 2 dozen rabbits! There is only so much one person can do!

Posted by: Suzanne | December 20, 2008 12:31 PM

i just don't believe he's that stupid!!!! AND, TO BOOT, if you just have to have a 'pure' bred dog, there is a rescue organization for every breed you can think of!! YES, even the so-called 'fancy' ones. as i type, i sit next to a 'pure' poodle and a 'pure' maltese -- both from their respective rescue organizations. they came from DEPLORABLE conditions. if he HAD to have a german shepherd, he could have done himself a huge favor to seek out a german shepherd rescue group, because that's where all the poor dogs that don't get bought from the breeder he helped out will end up!!! that, of course, is unless you intended to breed it (god forbid) because the extremely small cost (if any) covers the alteration, shots and anything else the dog may need. if you can afford it (clearing throat, because you OBVIOUSLY can), please consider paying to the rescue group what you would have paid these damn breeders. joe biden, you live in a dog-lovin' country, for shame. PEOPLE, REMEMBER TO CHECK FOR AN ORGANIZATION THAT RESCUES THE BREED YOU WANT!! even if you have to drive a little, say to a big city, you'll still come out cheaper! and, i SWEAR they know what you did and will love you forever like nobody ever has. forget the 'i have to raise it from a puppy crap' (and they have those too!!!) did i say FOR SHAME?

Posted by: suse | December 20, 2008 12:45 PM

I LOVE that video (or commercial- whichever it shall be called)! I think it should air everywhere on every channel. It's so true! My dog is adopted, my cats were strays that we still have, and my horses were adopted. ADOPTION IS THE WAY!

Posted by: Danielle | December 20, 2008 12:51 PM

Just because there are animal shelters, does not mean one HAS GOT to BUY their pet at the animal shelter. I tried to adopt a kitten. The shelter had so many demands. I refused to allow the 'shelter' the privilige of determining where my cat would live. My cats stay in a heated garage... oh how horrid said they. I went to a pet store. And no longer support the financial needs of the shelter.

Posted by: Rena | December 20, 2008 12:59 PM

Everyone Write Biden and let him know how dissapopinted you are in his actions. Write Obama and let him know how you feel about his number 2 man. People stand up for yourself and start the reality of "change".

Posted by: One MAD SOB | December 20, 2008 01:01 PM

Give Biden a break. Joe almost always supports and even sponsored or co-sponsored some animal rights bills. As stated before, there are some reputable breeders who usually breed just one litter at a time. If someone wants a purebread there's nothing wrong with that as long as it doesn't come from a pet store or a "mass breeder". Don't alienate one of our friends and don't look for Obama to adopt either. They have to find a hypoallergenic dog due to one of the kids. So they will probably be getting a purebread too.

Posted by: Wink | December 20, 2008 01:07 PM

Does this mean that if people dont't adopt a newborn child that this kills them too?

Posted by: Wise Woman | December 20, 2008 01:13 PM

Now that he knows better, next time he'll do better.

Posted by: Susan | December 20, 2008 07:39 PM

I also am not happy that Biden got his dog from a breeder. Maybe he could get a companion animal for his dog, then he would look a little better to all of us that care for shelter animals. I also think the video is powerful.

Posted by: Kathleen Simmons | December 20, 2008 08:14 PM

Don't dogs from breeders deserve a home????

Posted by: Rodolfo | December 21, 2008 07:06 PM

Well, this is, because he (Biden) is a politician. That is that a politician does, isn't? promise for a better world, but that's pure... bla,bla,bla

Posted by: Claudia | December 22, 2008 11:45 AM

Truly Rodolfo!

Posted by: Xane | December 23, 2008 01:22 PM

There are a couple of different kinds of breeders, those that are responsible and are trying to better the line of dog and those that are there to make money. In any case a dog needs a home. and until breeding is regulated, by setting up certifications for the breeders so that they are educated, we will have those in it for money.

But first and foremost all dogs and cats need to be spayed or neutered. And the pounds and shelters that are adopting should not be adopting out without the animals surgery already being done. Discount vouchers are just paper, do you really think that small towns have the money to follow up on all of them to see that the surgeries have been done.

If the spaying and neutering is more regulated you would not have the millions of stray dogs hat need to die. Problem solved. But people are greedy and ignorant. I work in the veterinary field and have for 10yrs, always promoting the spay/neuter policy. The excuses are varied and go from one extreme to another on why they wont do it.

Then you have people promoting hybrid dogs. HYBRID DOGS ARE NOT BREEDS THEY ARE MUTTS THAT COST A LOT OF MONEY. you cannot breed a labradoodle with labradoodle and get a labradoodle. You have to have a lab and a poodle.

So stoning Mr Biden because he is one of millions who bought a dog from a breeder, because he was looking for a specific type of dog for his family, I cannot agree with. However, if he does not spay or neuter said animal I will help and throw the first stone.

Posted by: Kate | December 23, 2008 04:09 PM

A shelter dog will give so much love because they are thankful to be alive. My cat was adopted and is extremely grateful - it obvious to anyone who meets her. It would be nice for a politician to take a strong stand against puppy mills and by adopting a pet from a shelter will drastically increase the rate of adoptions, thus saving so many lives.

Posted by: Cynthia | December 23, 2008 07:05 PM

this is just a shame!the money he paid for a special breed dog is a disgrace.the animals you get at a shelter are very loving animals even though they may not be a highly breed dog they are wonderful pets. because i know. once again you let a dog down and that poor thing suffered thanks to you!!!!!!

Posted by: BONNIE ASKEY | December 24, 2008 08:28 AM

This is powerful. Will any of the stations broadcast it as a public service announcement?

That is one of the strongest statements made on film that i remember seeing. Best of all it would probably be given a G-rating.

Posted by: Teri | December 25, 2008 12:02 AM

Although I agree that it may have been a better choice for him in the public eye to rescue a dog rather then buy one from a breeder, there is NO shame is buying a dog from a breeder in my opinion. I have rescue dogs, its my personal choice to do so. However it seems you people are collectively saying that the dogs breed are less worthy of having a happy home then a rescue dog. The fact is ALL dogs deserve to go to a good home, no matter where they come from. If you want to get upset and fight for a cause, fight for where ANY and ALL dogs wind up and that the people who take care of any dog treat them well. No matter where that dog comes from.

Posted by: Jessica | January 4, 2009 08:45 PM

Rena.. you are ignorant. Not being supportive of a shelter is just plain stupidity. Have you seen any footage of Puppy mills?... because that is what you are supporting when you buy a pet from a store. You are an idiot. And why even have a pet if they are not going to be IN your home?

Posted by: Janis Bates | January 6, 2009 12:53 PM

Never expected this from you (Being Ignorant ?)

Posted by: preeti | April 7, 2009 09:21 AM

Listen before you people get all up in arms about the Obama's dog let me tell you some things. NON SHED puppies are hard to get at shelters, I finally got one after nearly 2 years of trying. I only adopt dogs from shelters. They come in and go out in about a week or less. The kids have allergies so they need a non shed pup not A MIX. Also shelter pups come from puppy mills most of the time. They come with problems, many are shy. Just go to shyk9 at yahoo to read all the posts from people who own them. I love my pup, but she's been a project and I am still working on trying to get her over her fears. Not a dog you want to throw on a busy family with kids. While it would be nice for Biden to adopt a older dog from a shelter maybe he wanted a puppy. You can't force someone to want something. Lets just hope the dog wasn't from a puppy mill. I don't understand why your group wants to crucify good breeders. The problem isn't them it is the puppy mills that will put a responsible breeder out of business. It is a good idea to check a shelter first before you purchase a dog but if you don't find the one you like go to a reputable breeder. I am sure the Bidens thought they did.

Posted by: Gail | April 11, 2009 06:46 PM

I don't see why Joe has to be forced into adopting a puppy from a shelter if he wants to buy one from a breeder , you guys want to adopt all the puppies from the shelters well good for you ,but Joe did nothing wrong ,in fact I'm a go buy me one as soon as I can and it has nothing to do with protesting against anyone ,it's my personal desire to do so....!

Posted by: mario | April 13, 2009 03:59 PM

my letter to senator kennedy:

DEAR SENATOR KENNEDY:

Bo is a pure bred Portuguese water dog, a relatively rare breed, whose breeder, Martha Stern, said is not a "rescue". She explained dogs that don't work out are returned to her and she will sell them to someone else. There is no chance a dog like this would ever have needed rescuing.

If OBAMA cannot even honor a SIMPLE promise to adopt a shelter dog-what makes you think he will honor more important key issues? This tells you a lot about him: It's no longer about a dog, but it's the ability to keep a promise.

Now word is spreading fast about Obama's inability to make good even with a simple promise. This dog thing is deeper than you think.

Posted by: Luke | April 15, 2009 11:54 AM